thanks poisoninthestain, so it's unlikely swim's hgcl2 is decomposed then. he was assuming it had either a) decomposed somewhat or b) was contaminated with other salts to some degree.
is there any way to test the purity of hgcl2? of course you can run a test amalgam but for someone who's never run the al/hg reduction before it's hard to tell just how "on point" the amalgamation is going. it's important to know the purity of the hgcl2 so you don't get a dead al/hg or a volcano.
for example swim had a dream where he tested a little bit of hgcl2 in MeOH with a couple balls of al. it took a long time, several hours probably, but it eventually melted the al down to goop. one would imagine that a test of this nature without any additional reactions happening to cause an exothermic reaction, that the amalgam would indeed take several hours to complete so swim supposes this is ok.
but swim is worried about the purity of hgcl2 because it only partially dissolves in MeOH and h2o, signaling the presence of contaminant salts unless hgcl2 isn't quite as soluble as it's reputation makes it seem. most of his hgcl2 dissolves, especially in ethanol which is weird that it didn't dissolve as quickly in methanol. anyway, he'd rather just scale up the contaminated hgcl2 to meet the required amount of pure hgcl2 rather than recrystallize it, he's quite tired of dealing with this nasty stuff in dreams.
here's a procedure of something he read about online to help identify possible contaminant salts or whether or not some of the salts were indeed decomposed, yields seem a bit too high so he's wondering about contaminants:
day 1:
added 20g elemental Hg to a 500ml flat bottom flask
added 60ml h2so4 to the same flask
cranked up high heat and put a stirbar on medium
soon as heat the picked up, noticed vigorous bubbles (boiling) of so2 formation, loads of so2 fumes pouring out of the flask
the solution progressed to yellow, then orange, then brown
at the end of the first hour, noticed particles in the solution, backed off the heat just a little bit
at the 3 hour mark, noticed solution was still fuming but much less than earlier. turned off heat and turned off stirbar
the solution was clear and orange/brown, dangerous but absolutely beautiful bright white crystals encrusted all over the upper part of the flask's neck, think the stirring was a bad idea or perhaps too much heat. the bubbles/stirring probably projected the precipitated crystals up along the inside of the flask. there is even some crystals on the hotplate and clamp, swim hates working with this stuff
stopped for the day, sealed the flask with plastic wrap and put it in the dark
day 4:
added 166ml brine solution to the HgSO4, at first added a couple drops and it reacted exothermically due to the remaining h2so4. however there was not much h2so4 left (pipetted off most of it) so it only got exothermic enough to dissolve some of the hgso4
put the flat bottom flask back on the hotplate with stirring set to low, set the heat to about 70-80C and eventually all the hgso4 dissolved in the brine solution. no yellow precipitate was noticed
turned off the heat and let it cool off
added 100ml saturated NaOH solution, brilliant flashes of bright orange appeared briefly as the NaOH was added
added another 200ml saturated NaOH solution, more flashes of bright orange appeared, the aqueous solution began to turn yellow then orange as yellow/orange precipitate fell out of the solution. could have added another 100-200ml saturated NaOH solution until aqueous layer turned brown to make sure all HgO has precipitated however the flask is almost full and don't want to use any more flasks for this hideous stuff, so will just take the loss
gave the HgO time to settle at the bottom, then decanted the orange aqueous solution
the remaining precipitated HgO was washed 2x with 200ml dh2o and decanted to help remove NaCl and NaOH from the brine and NaOH solutions used. a little HgO was sacrificed because swim wanted to decant as much water off each time as possible to get rid of contaminant salts, both times the HgO was allowed to settle before decanting the dh2o
added 366ml dh2o (enough for the HgCl2 to dissolve in after formation)
added hcl solution (100ml dh2o + 20ml 33% hcl) dropwise until the solution turned colorless (and cloudy from precipitate - not enough water to dissolve all the HgCl2?)
stopped for the day and put the flask in the dark
day 5:
noticed some white precipitate on the bottom of the flask and the water was clear, added more dh2o in hopes that this precipitate would dissolve in it, assuming it is HgCl2
upon addition of extra dh2o the solution became cloudy again but it looked like most of it did dissolve
poured the solution into a glass dish (never to be used for consumables ever again) on a hotplate with the heat set to about 80C
over the course of about 5-6 hours the water evaporated and left a white powder, many needle-like crystals on the sides and a big pile of powder in the center where the water collected before it was dissolved entirely <- this is where the apparent sublimation occurred as stated in previous post and the salts became very compact and caked together
salts were scraped up to yield 19.76g
test amalgam #1:
a mason jar was filled with 50ml tap water, a little bit of HgCl2 was added to the water. most of it dissolved but some did not, added 2 balls of aluminum foil
checked back 15 minutes later and nothing has changed, some HgCl2 still sitting on the bottom undissolved but not much, some 95% EtOH was added to help solubility
checked back 20 minutes later and the aluminum foil balls were flattened (melted) and sizzling a little bit
checked back a couple hours later and saw a gray solution with no undissolved aluminum foil
test amalgam #2:
a mason jar was filled with 30ml anhydrous MeOH, a little bit of HgCl2 (2 knife tips worth) was added to the MeOH, some dissolved but most just sat, clumped on the bottom of the jar. some agitation and stirred helped dissolve some of it but still all did not dissolve. added a couple heavy duty al foil balls
checked back 30 minutes later and some of the coating of the al had been eaten away to show a darker gray area of the al but still a great deal of the AlO coating was present
checked back another 30 minutes later and not much else changed, al looked a little more flattened
added a couple drops of nitromethane to see if it would heat up at all, it did absolutely nothing
checked back the next day and the mason jar had nothing more than an obliterated pile of al goo, broken down al foil saturated in MeOH most likely
swim thinks he used too little solvent but it was enough to completely cover all the al foil (before it was amalgamated) but still thinks there was just too much al foil and too little solvent